While Cameron’s theory is based on a good knowledge of the disaster, there are still many holes. They were notoriously hesitant to get in the lifeboats, so the chances of them evacuating the ship to sleep on a huge chunk of ice are much lower and the whole process could’ve lost the team precious time and caused even more deaths. Titanic (1953) - Movies, TV, Celebs, and more. In the panel, one member also raises the problem of actually convincing the passengers to mount the iceberg. James Cameron might have accurately recreated the ship’s destruction in his movie, gathering plenty of knowledge on the matter, but the experts still believe this theory is too risky to work. If the waters surrounding the ship were cold enough to kill most of the travelers, the iceberg itself could be too. Icebergs are also incredibly cold, and while Cameron believes that people could spend a night in a “ fur coat” without freezing to death, the possibility still exists. The first obvious criticism is that icebergs aren’t designed to hold 2,000 people at once since their “ pretty irregular” form would be difficult to mount.
It’s obviously a flawed plan, but as all experts on the panel agree, there was no completely safe method of survival on that ship.Īlthough Cameron’s theory seems to make sense on the surface, there are plenty of historians, scientists, and engineers that disagree with the idea.
He argues that access to the iceberg would be simple enough since the ship “ just ran into it,” so the actual logistics of evacuating wouldn’t be too difficult. The director acknowledges that his theory isn’t completely safe, but he argues that it’s the most logical way to ensure those travelers aren’t forced into waters that will undoubtedly kill them overnight.
Speaking to a panel of experts for National Geographic (via YouTube), Cameron claimed: “ My first favorite idea is to put everybody on the iceberg.” He goes on to argue that since the iceberg is the only thing that’s guaranteed not to sink, it’s the safest place for the residents of the ship to be awaiting help. The director’s theory might sound bizarre at first, but Cameron believes that if the TItanic’s captain had made the decision to evacuate the travelers onto the iceberg itself, they may have survived long enough for rescue to come and save them.
0 kommentar(er)
